Here is a list of the 63 hymns (text-tune pairings) found in all eight of the hymnals at my disposal that are used by Evergreen Baptist Association English-language congregations:
A mighty fortress is our God
Ein' feste BurgAbide with me fast falls the eventide
Eventide Alas and did my Savior bleed
HudsonAll hail the power of Jesus' name
CoronationAmazing grace how sweet the sound that
New BritainAngels from the realms of glory
Regent Square Angels we have heard on high
Gloria Be still my soul
Finlandia Beneath the cross of Jesus
St Christopher Blessed assurance Jesus is mine
Assurance Blest be the tie that binds
Dennis Break thou the bread of life
Bread of Life Breathe on me breath of God
Trentham Christ the Lord is risen today
Easter HymnCome thou almighty King
Italian HymnCome thou fount of every blessing
NettletonCome we that love the Lord
Marching to ZionCome ye thankful people come
St George's WindsorFaith of our fathers living still
St CatherineFor all the saints who from their labors rest
Sine NomineGo tell it on the mountain
Go Tell It God of our fathers whose almighty hand
National Hymn Great is thy Faithfulness
Faithfulness Hark the herald angels sing
Mendelssohn Holy holy holy Lord God almighty
Nicaea How firm a foundation
Foundation I am thine O Lord I have heard thy voice
I Am Thine I come to the garden alone
Garden I love to tell the story
Hankey I need thee every hour
Need It came upon the midnight clear
Carol Jesus keep me near the cross
Near the Cross Jesus shall reign where'er the sun
Duke Street Joyful joyful we adore thee
Hymn to Joy Just as I am without one plea
Woodworth Let us break bread together on our knees
Let Us Break Bread Love divine all loves excelling
Beecher Mine eyes have seen the glory of the coming
Battle Hymn More love to thee O Christ
More Love to Thee My hope is built on nothing less
Solid Rock O beautiful for spacious skies
Materna O come all ye faithful
Adeste FidelesO come O come Emmanuel
Veni Emmanuel O for a thousand tongues to sing
Azmon O God our help in ages past
St Anne O little town of Bethlehem
St Louis On a hill far away stood an old rugged cross
Old Rugged Cross Rejoice ye pure in heart
Marion Rock of Ages cleft for me
Toplady Silent night holy night
Stille Nacht Sing them over again to me
Words of Life Softly and tenderly Jesus is calling
Thompson Sweet hour of prayer
Sweet Hour The church's one foundation
AureliaThere is a name I love to hear
O How I Love Jesus There's a sweet sweet Spirit in this place
Manna We gather together
KremserWere you there when they crucified
Were You ThereWhat a fellowship what a joy divine
Showalter What a friend we have in Jesus
Converse What child is this
Greensleeves When I survey the wondrous cross
Hamburg When peace like a river attendeth my way
Ville du Havre The complete list of the texts and tunes in the eight hymnals is in a spreadsheet at
this location on the Fremont Baptist website. I've tried to treat various modernizations and inclusive rewrites, wherever possible, as "the same as" their older versions; details can be found in the notes in the spreadsheet. I probably missed a couple of those, however, where the
New Century Hymnal's first line differs drastically from the received text.
Note that a text that is not uniformly found with the same tune may be underreported. For example, "Away in a manger" is in all eight hymnals, but failed to make the "universal" list because although seven of the hymnals give it to
Mueller (aka
Away in a Manger, the eighth gives it only to
Cradle Song (four of the hymnals give both tunes).
I would be thrilled to receive feedback triggered by these data.
Leland